HomeLITERATUREGender: Sex, ...

Gender: Sex, Social Construction and Patriarchy

-

Reading Time: 14 minutes

Gender is one of the fundamental concepts in sociology, cultural studies, feminist theory and in current debates about identity and social organisation. It enables us to understand how societies categorise people, assign roles and responsibilities, regulate behaviour, distribute power and create the expectations that we have of men and women and other gendered identities. It is of course intimately linked with biological sex, though the two are not the same. Sex refers to the biological characteristics of a person (reproductive anatomy, chromosomes, hormones, secondary sex characteristics etc). Gender is the set of meanings, roles, identities and expectations that a society ascribes to sexed bodies. Gender therefore operates at both the level of the individual and at the level of institutions, the family, the workplace, religion, the education system, the media and the political system.

Gender became a very important area of study through the work of feminist scholars who challenged the notion that the differences between the sexes were entirely natural or biologically based. The feminists showed that what we tend to think of as ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ is very much a product of socialisation and of cultural processes. Gender studies has since grown to encompass the experiences of women, men, trans people, non-binary people and indeed anyone whose experience doesn’t fit neatly into the male/female dichotomy. Gender is thus best understood as a combination of body, identity, socialisation, the institutions in which we live and the relations of power that shape our lives.

Introduction to Gender

The term ‘gender’ refers to the social and cultural meanings attached to being male, female or otherwise gendered in a particular society. It encompasses the expectations associated with appearance, behaviour, work, family roles, sexuality, emotional expression, status and so on. A society may for instance have a culture in which boys are expected to be assertive, independent and emotionally restrained while girls are expected to be caring, modest and accommodating. These are not simply descriptions of behaviour but are in fact rules about how people are supposed to behave.

Gender starts to impact the individual from a very early age. Families will dress the child differently, give them different toys, give them different jobs around the house and will praise different things in them. The process continues in schools, in the church, in the peer group, in the films and TV, in the adverts and on social media with all of these reinforcing the idea of what is appropriate masculine and what is appropriate feminine behaviour. The child is gradually learning what their society expects of each gender.

Gender is both a personal and a social construct. On the personal level it is to do with the individual’s sense of identity. On the social level it determines how others see and react to that individual. A person will be rewarded for conforming to gender norms and punished, excluded or discriminated against for challenging them. Gender norms will have an impact on the choices people make in education, the types of job they take, the expectations placed on them in the family, their clothing, their freedom of movement and their involvement in public life.

Gender also varies from culture to culture and from period to period. What is considered to be masculine in one society may not be at all in another. The gendering of clothing, occupations, modes of emotional expression and family roles can all be very different at one time in history from what they were at another time. This is of course important as it demonstrates that gender is not a fixed, universal system.

Gender is therefore a much broader concept than simply the differences between men and women. It’s about how societies create categories, what they mean by those categories and how they structure their social lives around those categories. It’s about the interaction of gender with all the other social categories we have (class, caste, race, ethnicity, religion, sexuality, disability and age). Gender inequality is not experienced in the same way by everyone as people are in multiple social positions at once.

Sex and Gender

The ‘sex/gender’ distinction became extremely influential in 20th century feminist thought in that it undermined the notion that social inequality between the sexes was simply a product of biology. At its most fundamental level it is the idea that sex is primarily about biological characteristics and gender is primarily about the social and cultural meanings attached to those characteristics.

Sex is generally defined in terms of physical attributes such as chromosomes, reproductive organs, hormones and secondary sex characteristics. Human bodies are typically classified as male or female on the basis of a combination of these characteristics. The reality is however that the biological picture is more complicated than a neat binary classification would suggest. Intersex variations are a case in point, showing that chromosomes, hormones, reproductive anatomy and external sex characteristics don’t always conform in the same way. Biology is therefore not a simple thing.

Gender on the other hand is about the roles, the expectations and the identities that societies construct around sex. The idea that women are naturally the ones to look after children, that men are the natural family breadwinners, that boys shouldn’t cry and that girls are the ones who are supposed to be particularly concerned with their looks are all examples of gendered expectations rather than biological facts.

The sex/gender distinction was of considerable political importance as it was a direct challenge to biological determinism. Biological determinism is the idea that social roles and differences in behaviour are primarily or entirely the result of biological sex. Feminist scholarship in particular was very much in the business of challenging the notion that women were by nature only suited to the domestic sphere, that they were by nature less rational, that they were by nature politically dependent or that they were by nature incapable of certain forms of intellectual or professional work.

The point can be made quite simply in terms of division of labour. Pregnancy and childbirth are obviously part of the reproductive biology. The idea that women therefore have to be the ones to do all the childcare, all the cooking, all the cleaning and all the emotional care is a social arrangement. Different societies have different arrangements for the division of domestic labour and those arrangements have changed over time. The ability to give birth does not in any way imply that you have to be the one to do all the work in the home.

Similarly the physical differences between the male and female body don’t explain why certain colours, occupations, hairstyles, styles of dress, expressions of emotion or domestic duties end up being linked to one gender or the other. Those associations are culturally constructed and perpetuated through the institutions of society.

More recent discussions have also stressed that sex and gender should not be seen as entirely separate. We experience our bodies through the cultural meanings attached to them and social expectations often arise in relation to bodily differences. Sex and gender therefore interact. The key point is that biological difference does not necessarily lead to social stratification in terms of personality, occupation or fate.

Gender identity is another layer to this. It’s about a person’s own sense of their gender. For many people it aligns with the sex they were assigned at birth. For some trans and non-binary people it doesn’t. That’s why gender can’t be reduced to just reproductive anatomy.

The sex/gender distinction is therefore still a useful one when it comes to looking at inequality. It enables us to ask whether a so-called ‘natural’ difference is in fact biological or whether it is in fact the result of social expectations which have turned a biological difference into a system of inequality and power.

Gender as a Social Construct

To say that gender is a social construct doesn’t mean that gender is fictitious or unimportant. It simply means that society as a whole creates, transmits and reinforces ideas about what different genders are. Those ideas become so entrenched that they may eventually seem entirely natural even though they can vary enormously from culture to culture and from time to time.

Gender is constructed through socialisation. From a very early age we are being socialised into the gender role that we are expected to adopt. We pick up the messages of what is appropriate for us through observation of who in the family cooks, who makes the money, who does the physical work and who provides the emotional support. We also learn it through stories, through our textbooks, through our religious texts, through advertising, through television, through the films we watch and through all the digital media we consume. The more we are exposed to it the more it becomes the norm.

Language also plays a part in the construction of gender. Phrases like ‘boys will be boys’, ‘man of the house’, ‘career woman’ and the notion that certain jobs are ‘men’s jobs’ or ‘women’s jobs’ are all examples of this. Even apparently positive descriptions can be seen to reinforce the idea of restrictive gender roles, e.g. women being praised for their looks and men for their authority or strength.

Clothing is another good example. There’s absolutely nothing biologically inherent in any particular colour, fabric or style that makes it in any way ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’. Those are meanings which are culturally constructed and which can vary enormously from time to time and place to place. The same is true of occupations. Teaching, nursing, clerical work, engineering, politics and the military have all been gendered in different ways in different social contexts.

The notion of gender as socially constructed also goes some way towards explaining how gender norms can evolve. Women going to university, becoming politicians, working in fields which were previously the preserve of men and taking on a variety of roles in public life have all served to challenge previous assumptions about what women are capable of and what their place in society should be. Likewise the changing conception of fatherhood is such that it is increasingly recognised that men can be active caregivers rather than simply the economic provider.

Gender construction is maintained through both rewards and sanctions. Those who conform to the dominant gender expectations will be rewarded with social approval. Those who don’t will be ridiculed, excluded, discriminated against and in some cases, will even be subjected to violence. A boy who is seen to be vulnerable will be mocked for being ‘too feminine’ or not sufficiently masculine. A woman who is ambitious will be judged more severely than a man who is the same. The response to such behaviour is to maintain the gendered status quo by making it far easier to be ‘normal’ than to be ‘different’.

The idea of gender performance (a concept very much associated with Judith Butler) takes it further still. Gender is not something you simply possess. It is something that is produced through action, through speech, through dress, through bodily comportment and through social interaction. You don’t just have gender. Gender is produced over and over again through the actions we take. The very act of repetition makes it seem as though it is natural, even though it is in fact a socially constructed phenomenon.

Gender is socially constructed though that doesn’t mean that people can pick and choose any social meaning they like. You’re born into a social system. Families, the law, religion, education, work, the media etc all establish very strong expectations before you’re old enough to question them. Social construction is therefore a matter of both agency and constraint.

Gender is also constructed in very different ways according to class, caste, race, ethnicity, religion and sexuality. There is no such thing as a single experience of womanhood or manhood. The experience of an upper class woman will be very different from that of a working class woman for instance. Any gender analysis has to take these intersections into account rather than pretend that all women are the same socially as all men.

Understanding gender as socially constructed makes social change not only possible but imaginable. If unequal gender roles were entirely the product of nature they would be very hard to challenge. If they are historically and culturally constructed then they can also be questioned, negotiated and changed.

Gender and Patriarchy

Gender becomes so important when you look at it in terms of patriarchy (the system of society in which men, particularly certain groups of men, have disproportionate amounts of power and authority in the political, economic, familial, religious and cultural spheres). The term originally referred to the authority of the male head of the household, but it has been broadened by feminist theory to refer to the wider system of male dominance.

Patriarchy doesn’t mean that every individual man has power over every individual woman, nor does it mean that men are never disadvantaged or suffer. It simply refers to the pattern of institutionalisation in which masculinity and male authority have historically been the more valued form, with women and femininity being the ones that have been subordinated and/or restricted.

One of the most obvious sites of patriarchal organisation has been the family. In many societies men have been the legally and/or culturally recognised heads of household, property owners and the ones who made the decisions. Women have been the ones to do the unpaid domestic work and look after the children. Marriage has at various times been a mechanism for restricting a woman’s economic independence, her mobility and her legal identity. Although the legal systems in many parts of the world have changed dramatically, the unequal expectations of women in relation to domestic work and care giving have in many cases not changed.

Patriarchy also works through the economy. Women have been systematically excluded from certain jobs, paid less for the same work, had their property rights restricted and expected to take time out of their careers to look after the family. Even where the formal barriers have gone, the cultural assumptions that underpin those barriers can still have an impact on who gets hired, who gets promoted, who is given the opportunity to lead and the very nature of what is expected of people in the workplace.

Political institutions provide another example. For a very long time in many countries women were simply not allowed to vote and had no formal political representation. The campaign for the vote was therefore not just about the vote; it was about challenging the very idea that political authority was something that men possessed by right. The fact that women are still so underrepresented in many of the leadership positions today continues to raise questions about the extent to which gendered power is still the norm.

Patriarchy is also maintained through notions of sexuality and respectability. Women are often judged more harshly than men for their sexual behaviour, their clothing or their relationships. The concept of family honour can be attached to women’s behaviour in a disproportionate way and this can be used to control women’s sexuality and mobility. At the same time there is the pressure on men to be strong, to be heterosexual, to be competitive and to be emotionally in control.

This is a crucial point as patriarchal systems can also constrain men. Boys can be discouraged from being vulnerable, from being caring, from being emotionally open as these are all deemed to be ‘feminine’ attributes. Patriarchy therefore creates a hierarchy not just between the sexes but between different forms of masculinity and femininity. A man who doesn’t conform to the dominant ideals of masculinity is in a position of marginalisation.

Gender based violence is another manifestation of patriarchal power. Domestic violence, sexual harassment, sexual assault and coercive control are not simply individual incidents; feminist analysis frequently looks at the way wider inequalities, cultural norms and institutional failings allow such violence to occur. A society which sees male control as the norm and which blames the victim of violence against them is a society which is in fact upholding patriarchal power.

Media and cultural representation also play a part in maintaining patriarchal gender relations. Women are frequently represented in terms of beauty, sexuality, motherhood and their relationship to men. Men are more often the subject of representations of action, of leadership and of authority. The repeated nature of such representations can make the unequal gender roles appear to be the natural and preferred way of being.

Patriarchy should be understood as historically variable rather than as a single, monolithic system operating in all places. The form it takes varies enormously from culture to culture, from social class to religion to political system. Gender inequality can interact with caste, race, colonial history, economic inequality and all sorts of other power structures. That’s why contemporary gender studies so often employs the concept of intersectionality (a term associated with Kimberlé Crenshaw) to describe the way different forms of inequality can intersect.

The relationship between gender and patriarchy is therefore one of power. Gender creates the social categories and the social expectations that go with them. Patriarchy then organises those categories in a hierarchy. Male authority is often treated as the default, femininity is often associated with dependence or care and institutions will reproduce those assumptions even when individuals themselves don’t subscribe to them.

Patriarchy is by no means a universal or unchanging arrangement. It has been challenged and transformed in many societies through the actions of feminist movements, legal reform, education, changes in the nature of family life, greater economic participation by women and the challenge to traditional, restrictive ideas of what it means to be a man. To understand patriarchy is therefore not just to describe inequality; it is to understand the processes by which unequal gender relations are created, reproduced, contested and changed.

Gender, Power and Social Change

The ideas of sex, gender, social construction and patriarchy are all interlinked. The distinction between sex and gender is the one that separates the biological from the social. Social construction is the term we use to describe how gender roles are learned, reproduced and institutionalised. Patriarchy is the term we use to describe the way in which these gender differences tend to be translated into differences in power, opportunity and authority.

Gender should not be understood simply as a synonym for ‘women’ or as simply a matter of personal identity. It is a system by which societies organise bodies, roles, expectations and relationships. It shapes the way we understand ourselves, but it also has an impact on education, employment, family, politics, sexuality and access to resources.

The big contribution of gender studies has been to question what is taken to be natural. If you say a particular job is “men’s work”, if you automatically assume that childcare is a woman’s job, if you equate leadership with masculinity and if you discourage men from being emotionally vulnerable, gender studies will ask how those assumptions came about and who they actually benefit.

Recognising that gender roles are socially constructed doesn’t in any way erase biological difference. It simply means that biology can’t be used as an automatic explanation for social inequality. Human bodies are real of course, but the way societies interpret those bodies is through the lens of culture. The cultural lens can either open up or close down possibilities for individuals.

Gender analysis therefore provides the possibility of social change. If gender is historically constructed then it can also be historically transformed. Changes in education, in law, in employment, in the way we are represented in the media, in family life and in social attitudes can all challenge the inequalities that have long seemed to be the norm. The study of gender ultimately leads us to consider the ways in which societies turn difference into hierarchy and the ways in which more equal forms of society might be created.

Devika Panikar
Devika Panikar
Devika Panikar has been teaching English Language and Literature since 2006 and is an Associate Professor under the Directorate of Collegiate Education, Government of Kerala. She views teaching as both a vocation and a collaboration —an exchange of ideas grounded in empathy, communication, and creativity. Believing that proper education connects the classroom to life, she strives to inspire curiosity and critical thought in her students. This website reflects her ongoing journey as an educator, offering lecture notes and learning resources curated to enrich and support her learners.